If you’re on the hunt for an apartment in Philadelphia, chances are two names keep popping up: Fishtown and Northern Liberties. Once gritty, working-class neighborhoods, both have undergone rapid transformations over the past decade—evolving into two of the city’s most dynamic, creative, and sought-after areas to live.
But while they share a similar vibe and appeal, each has its own personality, pace, and perks. So how do you choose the right one for your lifestyle?
We’re breaking it down across the categories that matter most to Philly renters: nightlife, dining, arts & culture, public transportation, apartment styles, and rent prices. Whether you’re a young professional, creative spirit, or remote worker looking for the perfect urban home, this guide will help you decide where to put down roots.
1. Nightlife Vibes
If your ideal night out involves local breweries, live music, or innovative cocktails, both neighborhoods deliver, but with different energy.
Fishtown is where Philly’s indie heart beats the loudest. The area is packed with hip bars, underground music venues, and eclectic dive joints. Spots like Johnny Brenda’s, The Barbary, and Frankford Hall keep the energy high well into the night. There’s a raw, creative vibe here that draws in artists, musicians, and 20-somethings looking to mingle.
In contrast, Northern Liberties offers a more polished, upscale nightlife. You’ll find chic rooftop lounges, stylish cocktail bars, and cozy wine spots. Think more date-night-friendly than dance floor chaos. It’s perfect for young professionals who want to unwind in a more laid-back setting.
2. Dining & Culinary Scene
Foodies, take note. The Northern Liberties vs Fishtown food scene is a delicious toss-up.
Fishtown leans toward trendsetting, with new concepts popping up constantly. There’s Suraya (a Lebanese café, brand) Pizzeria Beddia, and countless vegan and globally inspired eateries. The neighborhood thrives on innovation, it’s where chefs go to experiment and diners go to be wowed.
Northern Liberties brings more comfort-driven, neighborhood classics to the table. You’ll find gastropubs, coffee shops, and bakeries nestled between boutiques. Heritage, North Third, and Cafe La Maude are local staples for a reason.
If you crave culinary adventure, Fishtown may be your pick. If you prefer cozy favorites, Northern Liberties has you covered.
3. Arts and Culture
When it comes to creativity and cultural experiences, both neighborhoods boast strong identities.
Fishtown is the bohemian’s dream. Murals, art galleries, and DIY performance spaces fill its streets. There’s always something unconventional happening, from open mic nights to street art festivals.
Northern Liberties, on the other hand, feels more curated. It has a rich artistic legacy but is now home to more design studios, pop-up art installations, and boutique retail with a creative edge. It’s artsy, but a little more polished than Fishtown’s grittier charm.
4. Public Transport and Accessibility
Both neighborhoods offer good access to Center City, but here’s how they compare:
Fishtown is well-connected by the Market-Frankford Line (the “El”), making it easy to get downtown or to the suburbs. Several stations like Girard and Berks are within walking distance of most Fish, In
Northern Liberties is a bit more spread out and may require a short walk to reach the nearest subway or bus stop. However, its walkability and bike-friendly streets make it a commuter-friendly neighborhood overall.
If public transit is a deciding factor, Fishtown edges ahead, especially for those relying on the El.
5. Apartment Styles and Living Spaces
Here’s where things really get interesting for renters.
Fishtown offers a mix of converted warehouses, sleek new developments, and quirky walk-ups. Many Philadelphia apartments in Fishtown embrace a blend of industrial and modern aesthetics, think exposed brick, high ceilings, and open layouts. You’ll also find a growing number of luxury apartment buildings in Philadelphia choosing Fishtown for its cool factor.
Northern Liberties feels a bit more refined. The apartments in Northern Liberties Philadelphia PA often include upscale mid-rise buildings, townhome-style units, and amenity-packed complexes. If you value elevators, concierge services, and rooftop lounges, Northern Liberties Philadelphia apartments may better fit your lifestyle.
6. Average Rent Comparison
Both neighborhoods are desirable, and that means rent isn’t cheap. But there are slight differences.
- Fishtown tends to be slightly more affordable, especially if you’re open to walk-ups or shared spaces.
- Northern Liberties skews higher, reflecting the newer builds and premium amenities.
That said, prices can vary block to block. As demand for apartments for rent in Philadelphia continues to grow, both neighborhoods are seeing price hikes. Budget-conscious renters may find better value in Fishtown, while those looking for upscale living often turn to Northern Liberties.
The Bottom Line: Fishtown or Northern Liberties—You Can’t Go Wrong
Ultimately, both Fishtown and Northern Liberties bring their own unique flavor to Philadelphia living. Whether you’re drawn to Fishtown’s indie energy and artistic edge or prefer the polished comfort and community vibe of Northern Liberties, you’re choosing a neighborhood with character, culture, and serious lifestyle perks.
Whichever you choose, you’ll be surrounded by creativity, community, and access to some of the most exciting apartments for rent Philadelphia has on the market. From loft-style walk-ups to luxury amenity-filled buildings, your next great apartment could be just a few blocks away.
Ready to make your move? Your perfect Philly apartment might be waiting—whether it’s in Fishtown or tucked within the vibrant Northern Liberties neighborhood.