Hiring the right SEO agency can directly impact your traffic, leads, and revenue. With 75% of businesses investing in SEO, competition is high, and so is the risk of choosing the wrong partner. Today’s SEO calls for a thorough understanding of search algorithms, user intent, content, and link-building techniques, not only of keywords.
Some agencies use outdated or risky tactics, while others deliver results through proven, ethical methods. The difference comes down to asking the right questions before you hire.
This guide covers the key questions to ask any SEO agency so you can avoid costly mistakes and choose a partner that drives real growth.
I. Understanding Their Core Philosophy and Approach
- What is your SEO philosophy, and how does it support long-term growth?
SEO is ongoing, not a quick fix. They should focus on ethical methods that build trust and value over time, not shortcuts or risky tricks.
- How do you keep up with Google’s algorithm changes?
They should regularly follow industry news, attend events, and update their strategies when search engines change.
- What happens during client onboarding in the first 30, 60, and 90 days?
They should explain how they start with audits, research, goal-setting, and when you’ll see progress.
- How do you handle all parts of SEO—technical, on-page, off-page, and local?
They need to cover everything: website health, content, links, and local SEO if relevant.
II. Team Expertise and Resources
- Who will be our primary contact, and what is their SEO experience?
You want a knowledgeable, experienced person, not a junior staff member.
- How big is your SEO team, and who handles what?
Look for specialists in technical SEO, content, link building, etc., not just one person doing everything.
- What SEO tools do you use?
They should use well-known tools like Ahrefs, Semrush, and Google Analytics to guide decisions.
- Do you outsource work? How do you maintain quality?
If they outsource, they must carefully check the quality and ensure it fits your brand and ethical standards.
III. Strategy and Execution
- How do you research keywords and find the best ones for our business?
They should look beyond popular words to find valuable keywords matching your customers’ search.
- What’s your content strategy to help us rank and convert visitors?
They should create applicable, well-optimized content and track how it performs beyond just rankings.
- How do you build backlinks ethically?
They should focus on genuine, high-quality links from relevant websites, avoiding spammy tactics.
- How do you find and fix technical SEO problems?
They should audit your site, prioritize issues, and work with your developers to fix speed, mobile usability, and errors.
Finding a reliable SEO Toronto agency can make a significant difference when looking for expert help to boost your online presence. Local agencies like RankLab specialize in understanding the Toronto market’s unique dynamics and consumer behavior, helping your business effectively target the right audience.
IV. Communication, Reporting, and Accountability
- What reports do you provide, how often, and what do they include?
Reports should be clear and regular (monthly or bi-weekly) and should show traffic, rankings, conversions, and tasks done.
- How do you measure success, & what KPIs do you track?
They should measure real business goals like traffic, leads, and sales, not just rankings.
- How often and through what channels will we communicate?
Expect regular calls, emails, quick responses, and tools to track progress.
- How do you handle surprises like algorithm updates that hurt rankings?
They should monitor changes, respond fast, explain the issue, and fix it quickly.
V. Experience and Track Record
- Could you forward case studies or success stories from similar companies?
Look for proof they improved traffic, rankings, and sales for clients like you.
- What’s your client retention rate, & why do clients stay?
A high retention rate means clients are happy and see ongoing value.
- Can we speak with some of your current or past clients?
Talking to references gives honest feedback about how they work.
- How do you analyze our competitors’ SEO?
They should study competitors’ keywords, backlinks, and content to find ways to outperform them.
VI. Contractual and Financial Considerations
- What services are included in your pricing structure?
Fees, what you get, and whether there are additional expenses should all be explained in detail.
- What is the contract length, and how can we end it if needed?
Look for fair terms with options to leave if the partnership doesn’t work.
- How do you get access to our website and data safely?
They should request secure, read-only access and protect your information.
- What do you expect from us to make the SEO work?
They want timely responses, content help, technical support, and good communication from you.
Optional Bonus Questions (If You Want to Go Even Deeper)
- Do you offer website design or development support if SEO-related technical changes are required?
This uncovers whether they can handle implementation or if you’ll need additional third-party resources.
- How do you approach SEO for multilingual or international websites (if applicable)?
Essential for businesses targeting global audiences or multiple language markets.
- What is your approach to E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) in SEO content strategy?
Vital for businesses in YMYL (Your Money, Your Life) niches like health, finance, or legal.
- What is your pricing structure? Are services packaged, tiered, or fully customized?
Helps you understand cost transparency and whether they’re flexible to your budget and needs.
The Final Step
These comprehensive questions will provide a robust framework for evaluating potential SEO agencies. Take detailed notes, compare responses across different agencies, and don’t falter to ask follow-up questions if anything is unclear.
Remember to consider:
- Their understanding of your business: Do they genuinely grasp your industry, target audience, and unique challenges?
- Their communication style: Are they transparent, responsive, and easy to understand?
- Their track record: Do they have demonstrable success stories and satisfied clients?
- Their ethical approach: Do their strategies align with white-hat SEO practices?
- Your gut feeling: Do you feel comfortable and confident entrusting your online visibility to them?
Hiring the right SEO agency is a significant investment. Still, with careful due diligence and the right questions, you can forge a partnership that propels your business to new heights in the ever-evolving digital landscape. Choose wisely, and watch your organic growth flourish.